Update: C$341K trauma from seeing bottled fly

|

Updating our Apr. 26, 2005 entry, from Canada: "A Windsor, Ont., man lost out on a $341,775 court judgment yesterday, when the Ontario Court of Appeal ruled that a bottling company should not have been held liable for triggering a phobia of flies that altered his personality and killed his sex life." No one in the Mustapha family consumed the fly, or any of the water that had come into contact with it, but Waddah (Martin) Mustapha said the unsettling sight had precipitated a disabling psychological aversion. The Ontario court -- applying Canada's costs-follow-the-event principle -- assessed $30,000 in costs against Mustapha. (Kirk Makin, "Appeal court rules against man haunted by fly in water bottle", Globe and Mail, Dec. 16; opinion in Mustapha and Culligan of Canada (PDF)).

Archives