Criticizes BidZirk on his blog, and survives

Eric Goldman calls the case of BidZirk v. Smith, filed by a South Carolina eBay reseller against the blogger who'd criticized its services, "a flagship example of how a pernicious and misguided plaintiff with a thin skin can ruin a blogger's life." Maybe "ruin" is no longer the operative term, since a federal court has just thrown out the case. Among the court's determinations: calling a company's founder a "yes man" is opinion and not actionable as defamation (Oct. 28 and, before that, Nov. 21, 2006; decision (PDF)). More: Ron Coleman fingers as a culprit the "American Rule" (no shifting of fees) under which "there is for all practical purposes no downside to suing someone on the most preposterous of grounds and losing -- hence making the bringing of meritless litigation a part of every large company’s toolkit for silencing criticism and destroying smaller competitors."