I’ve got some thoughts on the subject at Point of Law.
Related posts
In workplace
Chronicling the high cost of our legal system
Overlawyered
Point of Law- AAJ convention lists what's hot in class actions, politiciansThe annual trial lawyers convention is just around the corner, as members of the American Association for Justice gather in Philadelphia July 12-16th. The convention brochure, as always, makes for interesting reading. You get a good sense of new strategies...Carter Wood
- In other West Virginia legal newsWest Virginia Governor Joe Manchin has taken the unusual step of filing an amicus brief with the state Supreme Court of Appeals, asking the court to clarify the ability of DuPont to challenge a jury's award of punitive damages against...Carter Wood
- More West Virginia AG fee bounty; new featured columnIn West Virginia, a state where government hiring of private lawyers to pursue public lawsuits has been particularly controversial, four law firms including Hagens Berman are set to split $3.9 million for prosecuting an antitrust suit against Visa and MasterCard...Walter Olson
- Zach Scruggs Gets 14 MonthsThe government had suggested probation, but as the WSJ law blog (free!) reports, he has been sentenced to 14 months for misprision of a felony. The WSJ law blog says that this federal crime is committed by failure to report...Michael Krauss
- Around the web, July 2Kentucky jury acquits Melbourne Mills, the "too drunk to pay attention" fen-phen defendant, can't reach agreement on others [Ted @ OL] Related: Florida A&M says no one's proved $1 million law school donation from Ky. scandal's Shirley Cunningham came from...Walter Olson
- AAJ convention lists what's hot in class actions, politicians
- Volokh
- Happy Independence Day!Enjoy, and stay safe....Eugene Volokh
- You Don't Mess with the Gura:Odd factoid that I didn't know until today -- Alan Gura, the winning lawyer in the Heller v. D.C. Second Amendment case, was born in Israel....Eugene Volokh
- More on Reducing the Pain of Taking the Bar Exam:My post on reducing the pain of taking the bar exam has attracted eminent critics such as Jim Chen and Nancy Rapoport....Ilya Somin
- The VC's First Emmy Nomination:Colorado Inside Out is weekly public affairs roundtable program, on KBDI channel 12, one of the two PBS stations in Denver. Twice a year, the program tapes a Time Machine...David Kopel
- Viacom to Get Copy of Every Record of Every Access to Every YouTube Video?:...Orin Kerr
- Happy Independence Day!
In addition to the factors that you mentioned, another component of the decrease in carpal tunnel cases has been the use of EMG studies to determine the degree of injury. EMG studies give an objective assessment of the nerve impingement. This helps separate the real from the malingering. By making it a cut and dry condition, the insurance pays when there is a problem and does not when there isn’t. There is no need for attorneys or their added expenses. As it is also an easily fixed problem and can be quantitatively followed, people can not ride the disability system indefinitely. I guess in short, there isn’t money in it anymore for attorneys!
This may be a case of 50-50 hindsight. Now it seems obvious that there are no serious, life-altering risks from using a mouse, but was this clear in 1993? There was probably not enough data at the time.
Anyway, it’ll be interesting to see what happens in about 2035, when the first Nintendo players start hitting retirement age. Will we see an uptick in arthritis from hours spent frantically mashing the “A” button? It’s not out of the realm of possibility. I kind of doubt it will make any real impact.
(For my sake, I hope not!)
iNonymous, there’s already a diagnosis called “Nintendo Thumb.”
Walter’s point probably has merit. Now if we could just do something about the “bulging disc” causation fraud underlying such a high number of car accident lawsuits, we’d be getting somewhere.
The case of Toyota v. Williams 534 U.S. 184 (2002)http://supct.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/00-1089.ZO.html did a lot to stem the tide of carpal tunnel ADA lawsuits.
Product liability lawsuits decreased for two reasons. The keyboard lawsuits tended to be losers, and the companies making these products designed ergonometrically better features.