What makes the author of that comment so sure that Grandparents will make the right descision? The only rights for Grandparents that I am in favor of is that of first refusal of custody in the event the parents become incapacitated or negligent.

I can’t imagine how it is better for the child to legislate over a fit parent’s decision, especially when balanced against some arbitrary, unquantified, benefit that the forced presense of grandparents may provide.

The counter-editorial disturbs me by stating It is naive to assume that parents who are not abusive or neglectful will always make the right decision where their children are concerned.

That is a common-sense position, and generally true, but extremely frightening when used to advocate legislative intrusion.