perjury – Overlawyered

Crime and punishment roundup

Walter Olson — Thu, 07 Jun 2018 09:55:52 +0000

“Lawmakers must act now to close New York’s double jeopardy loophole,” claims New York Attorney General Barbara Underwood. Its what? [Kenneth Lovett/New York Daily News, Jacob Sullum/Reason, Jed Shugerman/Slate (defending closing of “loophole”), Jonathan Blanks on Twitter, earlier]
Speaking of pardon powers, Debra Saunders quotes me in column on Presidential pardons, Martha Stewart, Rod Blagojevich, Marc Rich, etc. [Las Vegas Review Journal/syndicated]
“California Town Hired Private Law Firm to Sue Citizens, Then Tried to Conceal Massive Costs” [Scott Shackford, earlier on Indio, Coachella, etc.] Bill passed by California assembly “would put an end to a practice in which several cities have been contracting with private prosecutors to handle nuisance abatement cases, then billing the impacted citizens thousands in lawyers’ fees.” [same]
“In light of the [Aaron] Persky recall, here are some studies on the impact of elections on judicial behavior. The story is consistent: elections make judges harsher, and there may be other costs as well (like lower-skilled people becoming judges).” [John Pfaff Twitter thread, earlier here, here, and here]
“CBP Sued For Seizing $41,000 From Airline Passenger, Then Refusing To Give It Back Unless She Promised Not To Sue” [Tim Cushing, TechDirt]
Even when suspects are in fact guilty, lies told to justify searches “corrupt the law in order to enforce it. That’s not how policing is supposed to work.” [Jonathan Blanks on Joseph Goldstein, New York Times investigation of police perjury (“testilying”)]

Tags: California, double jeopardy, forfeiture, judges, law enforcement for profit, New York, perjury

Crime and punishment roundup is a post from Overlawyered - Chronicling the high cost of our legal system

Orange County: government workers were not on clear notice not to lie in court, falsify evidence

Walter Olson — Tue, 10 Jan 2017 14:06:11 +0000

“Using taxpayer funds, government officials in Orange County have spent the last 16 years arguing the most absurd legal proposition in the entire nation: How could social workers have known it was wrong to lie, falsify records and hide exculpatory evidence in 2000 so that a judge would forcibly take two young daughters from their mother for six-and-a-half years?” The argument did not fare well as a hearing before Ninth Circuit Judge Stephen Trott: “I’m just staggered by the claim that people in the shoes of your clients wouldn’t be on notice that you can’t use perjury and false evidence to take away somebody’s children. That to me is mind boggling.” [R. Scott Moxley, OC Weekly; video]

Tags: Child Protective Services, Los Angeles, perjury

Orange County: government workers were not on clear notice not to lie in court, falsify evidence is a post from Overlawyered - Chronicling the high cost of our legal system

Garlock asbestos bankruptcy settlement

Walter Olson — Wed, 23 Mar 2016 16:29:56 +0000

The case famous for helping crack open some of the secrets of the asbestos litigation business has reached a settlement, which will apparently include a settlement (probably without admission of wrongdoing) of civil RICO claims against several law firms. The revelations in the Garlock bankruptcy helped to bolster evidence that “some victims and their lawyers tell one story in one venue and another someplace else to ‘double dip’ the system” in cases against separate defendants. [Sara Warner, National Courts Monitor/Huffington Post; earlier]

Tags: asbestos, bankruptcy, perjury

Garlock asbestos bankruptcy settlement is a post from Overlawyered - Chronicling the high cost of our legal system

Police and prosecution roundup

Walter Olson — Tue, 08 Jul 2014 04:05:30 +0000

“Emails show feds asking Florida cops to deceive judges by calling Stingrays ‘confidential sources.'” [Wired]
Trial penalty: mortgage fraud defendants in study fared far worse if they insisted on process of law to which they are notionally entitled under Constitution [Wes Oliver at Daniel Fisher’s; more on joint Duquesne Law/Pittsburgh Post Gazette study from reporter Rich Lord, first, second]
“‘Florida’s Worst Cop’ Finally Convicted of Something, May Be Headed to Jail” [Ed Krayewski, Reason, earlier]
“Plans to expand scope of license-plate readers alarm privacy advocates” [Center for Investigative Reporting, earlier here, here, here, here, here] But at least our sensitive personal information will be safe with the government! [Lowering the Bar]
“Challenges to ‘shaken baby’ convictions mounting” [Wisconsin State Journal, earlier]
A Pavlik Morozov for the Drug War? “Brave” Minnesota 9-year-old hailed for turning in parents on pot rap [Minneapolis Star-Tribune, background on Soviet youth hero]
“Police SWAT teams in Massachusetts form private corporations, then claim immunity from disclosure laws” [Radley Balko via @gabrielroth, more from ACLU report on police militarization]

Tags: Massachusetts, perjury, Pittsburgh, police, prosecution, surveillance

Police and prosecution roundup is a post from Overlawyered - Chronicling the high cost of our legal system

Police and prosecution roundup

Walter Olson — Tue, 06 May 2014 04:05:13 +0000

Virginia Gov. McAuliffe vetoes bill expanding procedural rights for motorists facing camera tickets [The Newspaper]
Attracting drug deals to town was money-making scheme for a Florida community’s law enforcers [Radley Balko] “Civil Asset Forfeiture: The Biggest Little Racket in Nevada” [Jason Snead and Andrew Kloster, Heritage; related, Evan Bernick on Georgia and Texas; Balko forfeiture roundup; and update, reform in Minnesota]
“Yes, it’s time to get rid of regulatory agencies’ paramilitary units” [Jason Pye, United Liberty]
(Some of) what’s wrong with “victim’s rights” laws [Steve Chapman]
A case study in overcriminalization: “Reforming the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act” [Vikrant Reddy, Texas Public Policy Foundation] More: Overcriminalization in North Carolina [Jim Copland and Isaac Gorodetski, Manhattan Institute]
“We emphatically reject the notion that due process of law permits the police to frame suspects.” [Third Circuit in Halsey v. Pfeiffer, allowing Byron Halsey to sue police after being wrongly imprisoned for 19 years in double murder case; Newark Star-Ledger] What to do about ongoing epidemic of police “dropsy” and “testilying”? [Balko]
Prince George’s County, Maryland police announce in advance they’re going to behave unethically over course of next week [Conor Friedersdorf] Update: police call off plan, claiming announcing it had value in deterring johns.

Tags: crime and punishment, Florida, Foreign Corrupt Practices Act, Georgia, Maryland, Nevada, North Carolina, perjury, police, red light cameras, Texas, Virginia

Police and prosecution roundup is a post from Overlawyered - Chronicling the high cost of our legal system

“Asylum fraud in Chinatown: An Industry of Lies”

Walter Olson — Mon, 24 Feb 2014 11:23:13 +0000

“All you would be asked is the same few rubbish questions,” said the lawyer. “Just make it up.” However, the 2010 conversation was being secretly recorded by the feds as part of an investigation that “has led to the prosecution of at least 30 people” including lawyers, paralegals and others employed by ten law firms, as well as a church employee “accused of coaching asylum applicants in basic tenets of Christianity to prop up their claims of religious persecution.” [Kirk Semple, Joseph Goldstein and Jeffrey E. Singer, New York Times] Earlier on asylum law here, here, here, etc..

Tags: asylum law, perjury

“Asylum fraud in Chinatown: An Industry of Lies” is a post from Overlawyered - Chronicling the high cost of our legal system

January 22 roundup

Walter Olson — Wed, 22 Jan 2014 04:05:48 +0000

Reminder: federal panel finally mulling reform of ultra-costly pretrial discovery, now’s the time to send comments [Kyl/WSJ, earlier]
Michigan woman convicted of false rape claim had sent man to prison for 10 years in earlier case [ABA Journal]
Strickland, key figure in disastrous CPSIA law and then chief at NHTSA, lands at BigLaw’s Venable [AutoNews, Detroit News]
A religious accommodation too far? Devout student at secular university asks not to work with female classmates [York U., Ontario; CBC via @amyalkon, also related on Nova Scotia aikido class] Inviting shop clerks to set up “no booze/pork” check lines is a sensitivity too far [Andrew Stuttaford, Secular Right]
“Top 2013 Jury Awards: Price-Fixing, Nursing Home Liability, Defamation” [Margaret Cronin Fisk, Bloomberg] Top legal ethics stories of 2013 [Legal Ethics Forum and followup on R v Farooqi & Ors]
Liberate history-talk: “Another Battle Against Silly Tour-Guide Regulations” [Ilya Shapiro] Handing out $1,000 fines in Charleston, S.C. [Brian Doherty]
“The line between Salon and Granma is getting awfully blurry” [@dandrezner; more about DoNotLink.com]

Tags: CPSIA, discovery, ethics, perjury, religious discrimination, South Carolina

January 22 roundup is a post from Overlawyered - Chronicling the high cost of our legal system

Crime and punishment roundup

Walter Olson — Tue, 14 Jan 2014 04:05:15 +0000

Under new Illinois law, third offense of tossing cigarette to ground will be a felony [Andrew Stuttaford]
“The New York Times calls for prosecutors to establish an ‘open file’ policy to combat prosecutorial misconduct.” [Nicole Hyland, LEF; New York Times; Radley Balko, whose column at the Washington Post has now launched]
“Three Arrests Illustrate the Impact of New York’s Silly Seven-Round Ammunition Limit” [Jacob Sullum]
Forfeiture reform on the agenda in Michigan? [John Ross/Reason, Institute for Justice, earlier]
Speaking of law enforcement for profit, more on the proliferation of fees and third-party collectors that can land minor miscreants in “debtors’ prison” [Fox News; related, Balko]
“Want to stop repeats of Columbine and Newtown? Deprive mass killers of the spotlight. Can the media do that?” [Ari Schulman, WSJ via @garyrosenwsj]
“She’s regretted the lie that sent him to prison ever since.” [NY Mag]

Tags: crime and punishment, forfeiture, guns, Illinois, law enforcement for profit, Michigan, perjury, prosecutorial abuse

Crime and punishment roundup is a post from Overlawyered - Chronicling the high cost of our legal system

Roger Clemens acquitted on all counts

Walter Olson — Tue, 19 Jun 2012 04:36:20 +0000

Story at USA Today and CBS News. Among those who had questions about the prosecution from the start: Tom Kirkendall. Also see: Ron Coleman.

More: What jurors might have disliked about both the Clemens and the John Edwards prosecutions; a New York Sun editorial on the Clemens acquittal; Sally Jenkins, WaPo, via Fran Smith.

Tags: baseball, perjury

Roger Clemens acquitted on all counts is a post from Overlawyered - Chronicling the high cost of our legal system

“I don’t feel good about it — lying to people”

Walter Olson — Mon, 03 Oct 2011 14:35:46 +0000

A New Yorker writer sympathetically if uneasily profiles one of the many who choose to pursue legal immigrant status (with lawyers’ help) by petitioning for asylum on the basis of made-up atrocity stories. “‘I have never been raped,’ she admitted, giggling with embarrassment… ‘Telling that story makes me sad, because I know it’s true for someone.'” But not necessarily true for most of those in her position: “There’s one [a story] for each country,” explains a lawyer. “There’s the Colombian rape story — they all say they were raped by the FARC. There’s the Rwandan rape story, the Tibetan refugee story. The details for each are the same.” [Suketu Mehta, “The Asylum Seeker: For a chance at a better life, it helps to make your bad story worse,” New Yorker](& Legal Ethics Forum)

Tags: asylum law, immigration law, perjury

“I don’t feel good about it — lying to people” is a post from Overlawyered - Chronicling the high cost of our legal system