Schools for Misrule – Overlawyered

Feds and states bless ABA’s gatekeeper status in law school accreditation. Why?

Walter Olson — Thu, 04 Oct 2018 09:55:39 +0000

The American Bar Association (ABA)

has been granted monopoly status over the accreditation of law schools by the U.S. Department of Education (for purposes of determining eligibility for federal student loans) and nearly all state supreme courts (for purposes of determining eligibility to take the bar exam). Monopoly status is inevitably prone to abuse, and in recent decades the ABA has gone far beyond its original mission of establishing minimum standards for legal education to protect the public. Professor John Baker maintains that “the ABA is an ideological organization forcing its ideology into the standards on accreditation.”

I found while researching my book on legal academia, Schools for Misrule, that the ABA’s and AALS’s (Association of American Law Schools) role as accreditors has had far-reaching structural effects on law schools and probably ideological effects too, as well as restricting competition and discouraging innovation. I agree with Mark Pulliam that the federal government and states should refrain from artificially promoting these groups’ gatekeeper role or, worse, conferring monopoly status on them [Law and Liberty]

Feds and states bless ABA’s gatekeeper status in law school accreditation. Why? is a post from Overlawyered - Chronicling the high cost of our legal system

Relaxing the ABA’s rules on law school faculty structure

Walter Olson — Thu, 13 Apr 2017 09:55:40 +0000

The American Bar Association is proposing easing its mandate that law schools use full-time faculty for at least one-half of courseload; the new minimum would be one-third. The shift would be a step toward reviving the once-common and generally less expensive model of law school oriented more toward training-for-practice and less toward scholarship and research. I recommended similar reforms in Schools for Misrule. [Paul Horwitz; Paul Caron and links]

Tags: bar associations, law schools, Schools for Misrule

Relaxing the ABA’s rules on law school faculty structure is a post from Overlawyered - Chronicling the high cost of our legal system

Intellectual diversity at law schools

Walter Olson — Tue, 28 Feb 2017 05:17:34 +0000

As I noted in my book Schools for Misrule a few years back, law faculties, especially at elite schools, tilt overwhelmingly leftward on the political spectrum. Last month the Association of American Law Schools turned down a request from conservative and libertarian legal scholars that a task force be set up to look into this issue and that data be released to help identify such patterns if indeed they exist. On Wednesday 28 dissident legal scholars went public with a letter urging a change of course. Here’s Josh Blackman’s post about the letter. Other signatories include Jonathan H. Adler, Randy Barnett, Gail Heriot, James Lindgren, John McGinnis, Nicholas Quinn Rosenkranz, Ilya Somin, Eugene Volokh, and Stephen Ware. More: Randy Barnett; Paul Caron/TaxProf with links.

More: AALS executive director Judith Areen responds.

Tags: law schools, Schools for Misrule

Intellectual diversity at law schools is a post from Overlawyered - Chronicling the high cost of our legal system

“I myself escaped by a bare whisker from attending law school…”

Walter Olson — Thu, 28 Jan 2016 05:15:32 +0000

My tell-all interview at Fault Lines gets into why I don’t hate lawyers (really), my various books, my views on Cato and other think tanks, law and economics, the lack of any real reckoning for the Great Tobacco Robbery, why law schools might actually serve as a counterweight to campus pressure for ideological uniformity, my writing outside law, and much, much more. I’m interviewed by Scott Greenfield, well known to our readers for his criminal law blogging; Fault Lines is a recently launched criminal justice website that’s part of Lee Pacchia’s Mimesis Law.

There have been many flattering reactions already, scroll down from the interview to this comment from Margaret Little which made me particularly happy:

Overlawyered made an enormous contribution to understanding where lawyers were taking the legal system over the past several decades and it continues to fill a vacuum in the discourse about law. For too long that discourse was plaintiffs vs. defense lawyers, with both sides vulnerable to attack for self-interest. Worse, the defense bar, which has an economic interest in the expansion of liability, is often silent or even complicit in the game. While Overlawyered’s postings were made with much-appreciated wit and style, the sheer comprehensiveness of the empirical data, and the mind-boggling attention to detail in its analysis makes it a gold mine for research and a landmark accomplishment. Well done! Don’t quit!

Whole thing here.

Tags: about the site, Cato Institute, interviewed, law schools, Schools for Misrule, The Excuse Factory, The Litigation Explosion, The Rule of Lawyers

“I myself escaped by a bare whisker from attending law school…” is a post from Overlawyered - Chronicling the high cost of our legal system

Law school embraces social-justice theme

Walter Olson — Thu, 14 Jan 2016 05:15:08 +0000

In 2014 the faculty of the Louis D. Brandeis Law School at the University of Louisville voted to commit the institution to “social justice,” and now plans are afoot to rebrand the public institution as the “nation’s first compassionate law school.” If everyone could settle on the same definitions of social justice and compassion, and maybe also agree that those values should trump others, the schools’ direction might look more neutral and scholarly, and less nakedly political. [Luke Milligan, Louisville Courier-Journal] U of L is hardly the first school to go down this path; as I note in my book Schools for Misrule, a number of law schools including some Top 30 institutions have veered off in the same direction in recent years, even before this year’s campus protests furnished considerable new momentum. But see: a second U of L lawprof dismisses the concerns as overblown, and points out that the school’s adoption of the word came in the context of a city-wide campaign in which various leading Louisville businesses and civic institutions had been prevailed on to declare themselves “compassionate.” [Caron/TaxProf]

P.S. If law schools want to jump into explicitly promoting social justice, John McGinnis has a modest proposal for how they might do that.

Tags: Kentucky, law schools, political correctness, Schools for Misrule

Law school embraces social-justice theme is a post from Overlawyered - Chronicling the high cost of our legal system

Annals of bonkers scholarship: “Trahison des Professeurs”

Walter Olson — Sun, 30 Aug 2015 20:38:16 +0000

I’ve seen a hundred wacky and extreme papers out of legal academia, and wrote about more than one in Schools for Misrule, but this one, published by the National Security Law Journal at George Mason (whose editor-in-chief has already repudiated it) stands out. You can read the whole story at The Guardian, including links to some of the controversies that have followed author William Bradford, but it might make more sense to hand the gavel over to distinguished legal scholar and Prof. Jeremy Rabkin in his four-page rebuttal:

When an article proposes to arrest law professors and bomb law schools and nearby TV studios, it’s not engaging in “controversy,” but slipping into an alternate universe. It’s not “discomforting.” It is bonkers. The journal could not reasonably have expected readers to “respond” – unless to ask, “Are you out of your minds?”

Monday update: Bradford resigns.

Tags: law schools, military, Schools for Misrule, terrorism

Annals of bonkers scholarship: “Trahison des Professeurs” is a post from Overlawyered - Chronicling the high cost of our legal system

Prof. Laurence Tribe flayed for arguing business side in SCOTUS cases

Walter Olson — Wed, 13 May 2015 09:35:36 +0000

And critics such as lawprof Tim Wu in the New Yorker aren’t ready to accept as an excuse the genuineness of Tribe’s belief in the argued-for positions [John Steele, Legal Ethics Forum] Perhaps the idea is that strong lawyers — like cartoonists? — have an obligation not to “punch down,” whether or not justice in a given case is on the side of the putatively less empowered party.

I’ve got an extensive discussion of law professors’ real-life litigation involvements in my book Schools for Misrule.

Tags: ethics, Harvard, law schools, Schools for Misrule

Prof. Laurence Tribe flayed for arguing business side in SCOTUS cases is a post from Overlawyered - Chronicling the high cost of our legal system

The imperfect diversity of Harvard Law School

Walter Olson — Mon, 04 May 2015 10:11:22 +0000

“98% Of Harvard Law Faculty Political Donations Go To Democrats” [Paul Caron, TaxProf]

If I say so myself, my book Schools for Misrule makes a good place to start in understanding how American legal academia came by its distinctive ideological leanings. There’s a Kindle version you can download right now.

Tags: Harvard, law schools, Schools for Misrule

The imperfect diversity of Harvard Law School is a post from Overlawyered - Chronicling the high cost of our legal system

Law-school-related opinion pieces that left me unconvinced

Walter Olson — Wed, 25 Mar 2015 04:15:38 +0000

From a Harvard lawprof: were today’s abundance of law schools to give way in part to a revived clerkship/apprentice model, American law would develop more slowly and organically than it does now, besides which where’d we train our philosopher-monarchs? [Noah Feldman, Bloomberg View] You can buy my recent book Schools for Misrule (including a Kindle download version) here.

Tags: law schools, Schools for Misrule

Questioning law schools’ role

Walter Olson — Sun, 03 Aug 2014 15:52:56 +0000

In Schools for Misrule, I had positive things to say about the “reading law” or apprenticeship alternative to law schools, and the New York Times “Room for Debate” feature now runs a roundtable on that question with contributors that include Brian Tamanaha, David Lat, and Erwin Chemerinsky. Much deeper disruption than that may lay ahead: “Within ten years, MOOCs [massive open online courses] could replace traditional law school classes altogether, except at a few elite law schools” [Philip Schrag via TaxProf] And are law schools pro-cyclical? The state of Florida saw a steeper boom and deeper bust in legal services than the rest of the country; it doesn’t seem to have helped that five new law schools have opened lately in the state, or that many Florida law schools succeed in placing fewer than half of their grads in paying positions for which bar passage is required. [TaxProf]

Tags: Florida, law schools, Schools for Misrule

Questioning law schools’ role is a post from Overlawyered - Chronicling the high cost of our legal system