In addition to liability and safety fears, the Americans with Disabilities Act turns out to play a role in the decline of swing sets at public playgrounds: it seems the least expensive way to make a swing set safer is to surround it with sand, but sand is considered a non-accessible surface for wheelchairs which makes it suspect under the ADA. (Scott Simonson, “Safety rules retiring playground standby”, Arizona Daily Star, Sept. 7). See Mar. 28, Aug. 23, etc.
Posts Tagged ‘schools’
“Recovered memory” doubter sued
Prof. Elizabeth Loftus, the psychologist whose writings and expert testimony have been highly influential in casting doubt on the reliability of buried and then putatively recovered memories of abuse (see Mar. 22 and links from there), is the defendant in a lawsuit filed by a “Jane Doe” abuse complainant whose allegations Loftus critically examined in a 2002 article for Skeptical Inquirer (the valuable magazine of CSICOP, the Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims for the Paranormal). Trial is expected soon: “If she loses, not only will academic freedom have arguably suffered a grievous blow, but on a personal level, Loftus herself could face bankruptcy.” “Jane Doe” also “filed an ethics complaint against Loftus with the University of Washington. Though the university eventually cleared Loftus of breaking research protocols — after seizing all of her files on the case and preventing her from publishing her work for almost two years — its support was so lukewarm, and its unwillingness to stand by its controversial psychologist during the current lawsuit so clear, that Loftus was only too happy to accept an offer from Irvine.” (Sasha Abramsky, “Memory and Manipulation”, L.A. Weekly, Aug. 20-26) (via Brian Doherty, Reason “Hit and Run”, Aug. 24). Update: see Jun. 26, 2005 (L.A. Times covers case).
Regulated recess
No games that involve chasing each other, kids. And whatever you do, don’t push each other on the swing, whether you’re just trying to be friendly or not. (Sandy Louey, “Recess gets regulated”, Sacramento Bee, Aug. 22). More on forbidden fun: Jul. 6, Apr. 15, 2004; Dec. 30, Dec. 26, Oct. 3, 2003; earlier items.
Obese Arkansas Schoolkids
You probably heard a couple of months ago that the state of Arkansas decided to start providing the parents of school children with “report cards” on their kids’ weight. School children will have their “Body Mass Index” (BMI) measured at school, and the results sent home. What I just learned today, from this MSNBC story, is where the funding originated for the obesity report cards: “The BMI test came into existence as a result of a cash windfall to the state from a tobacco lawsuit settlement tagged to fund public health programs.”
It’s particularly ironic because decreased smoking, apparently, is one of the major factors promoting the American obesity epidemic.
Update: U. of Utah settles won’t-swear actress’s suit
“The University of Utah agreed yesterday to let students opt out of activities that conflict with their religious beliefs, settling a lawsuit brought by a Mormon drama student who refused to recite lines that contained the F-word and took the Lord?s name in vain. Christina Axson-Flynn, 24, had sued the university in federal court, accusing it of violating her to right to freedom of speech and religion.” (“College, Mormon student settle theatrical-swearing case”, AP/First Amendment Center, Jul. 15; Elizabeth Neff and Shinika A. Sykes, “U. settles case over student’s rights on stage”, Salt Lake Tribune, Jul. 15). The “university will reimburse Axson-Flynn for tuition and fees paid during the 1998-99 academic year and, through the state’s risk management office, pay her attorneys’ fees of approximately $250,000.” (Angie Welling, “U., Axson-Flynn settle civil rights suit”, Deseret News, Jul. 15). See our coverage of Jan. 24, 2000 and Feb. 16, 2004.
Staggered sports schedules again found to violate Title IX
“Separate soccer seasons for girls’ teams in two Westchester, N.Y., school districts violate civil rights laws banning gender discrimination in athletics, the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled [last month].” The Mamaroneck and Pelham school districts had unsuccessfully argued that logistical concerns — notably a shortage of soccer fields to play on — justified the practice of having boys play soccer in the fall and girls in the spring. (Mark Hamblett, “Separate Soccer Found to Violate Civil Rights”, New York Law Journal, Jun. 8). For a similar ruling in Michigan, see Dec. 24-27, 2001; letter to the editor, Feb. 28, 2002. More: May 7, 2005.
U.K.: It’s sunny, stay inside
According to guidelines issued by the city council of the city of Derby, England, teachers who plan to lead students on summer trips should “consider keeping a supply of maximum factor suncream to spray onto pupils, although they are told not to rub it in for fear of being accused of inappropriate contact.” Meanwhile, in the city of Bristol, staff at Hillcrest Primary school confiscated a bottle of factor 60 sunblock that a mother had given her easily sunburned 8-year-old son to take to school, saying it was forbidden for students to possess medication and that the youth should instead have worn a long-sleeved shirt and sun hat. Perhaps as a concession to the intractable problem of achieving all the different kinds of complete safety at once, the Derby council guidelines urge educators to consider canceling field outings entirely on days that are too sunny. (“Schools warned over sunny trips”, BBC, Jun. 4)(via Common Good “EdWatch“); “School stops boy using sun cream”, BBC, May 4).
NEA lawsuit left behind?
The AP reports that the National Education Association’s plans to launch a legal challenge the No Child Left Behind Act have, thus far, come to naught. No state government has signed on to the proposed suit, announced a year ago, and NEA is rethinking its strategy. The NEA website offers its views on the Act here; Education Secretary Paige’s response to the NEA’s threat of a lawsuit last summer is here.
Another valedictorian suit
Oz: jilted wife wants stress damages too
Two months ago (see Apr. 8) a workers’ comp tribunal caused a furor in Australia by awarding $A28,000 to teacher Jeff Sinclair, who was fired over an affair with a teenage student. (“School for scandal”, Melbourne Age, May 3). Now Sabina Sinclair, the educator’s spurned wife, is also seeking compensation for psychological injury from the New South Wales education department over the incident. “I am really fragile,” she said. (Martin Wallace, “Jilted wife seeks damages”, Daily Telegraph/News.com.au, May 31).