The Michigan Court of Appeals has ruled that Carla Allen of Warren is not entitled to collect damages from her daughter for failing to maintain her property in a safe condition. Mrs. Allen tripped and fell “on a raised slab of concrete on her daughter?s driveway”. The “court ruled that when an average person with ordinary intelligence can discover a danger on casual inspection, as the mother could in this case, he or she cannot blame someone else for injuries.” The editorialists at the Detroit News say the case “speaks volumes about the absurd state of the U.S. judicial system” and suggests the need for more frequent sanctions. (“Fine Filers of Frivolous Lawsuits” (editorial), Detroit News, Feb. 24)
Mom sues daughter over driveway mishap
The Michigan Court of Appeals has ruled that Carla Allen of Warren is not entitled to collect damages from her daughter for failing to maintain her property in a safe condition. Mrs. Allen tripped and fell “on a raised slab of concrete on her daughter?s driveway”. The “court ruled that when an average person with […]
4 Comments
Family unity
The Michigan Court of Appeals has ruled that a mother cannot sue her daughter for failure to maintain her property in a safe condition. Court held that the mother was intelligent enough to discover a
Mom Sues Daughter Over Cracked Driveway
America is the most litigious society in the world. But surely things have gone too far when parents start suing their own children to collect for inadvertent injuries. Yet that is what a 58-year-old Warren mother did recently when…
Mom Sues Daughter Over Cracked Driveway
America is the most litigious society in the world. But surely things have gone too far when parents start suing their own children to collect for inadvertent injuries. Yet that is what a 58-year-old Warren mother did recently when…
Family Bonding
This may sound more insidious than it is, but a mother suing her daughter over a trip and fall on her property may just be a clever way for both of them to get at the homeowners insurance. Maybe the judge smelled it?or maybe her mother is just piece of…