On March 28, 2002, 14-year-old Francisco Belman asked to join the “Latin Mafia” gang at H.E. McCracken Middle School in Bluffton, South Carolina, an initiation that required him to be punched several times in the chest. Midway through the school bathroom ceremony, however, he collapsed and went into convulsions; the gang members tried for a few minutes to revive him with “sink water and paper towels.” School officials were eventually summoned, and gave Francisco CPR while waiting for paramedics; paramedics defibrillated, but Belman’s heart stopped again on the way to the hospital; Belman went into a vegetative state and died ten weeks later. So the parents have sued “the South Carolina Board of Education, Beaufort County Board of Education, town of Bluffton, Beaufort County Sheriff’s Office and the parents of the two boys who pleaded guilty this month to involuntary manslaughter in Francisco’s death.” Especially appalling is the newspaper’s editorial defending the lawsuit against peripheral players as an appropriate mechanism for the parents’ grief, but lapses into self-parody:
Clearly, the Belman family wants and deserves an apology. But from whom? The two boys who were trying to initiate Francisco into their club that fateful day have expressed remorse, and how could they not? They are teenagers; they didn’t know their machismo would ultimately kill Francisco.
(Stephanie Ingersoll, “Lawsuit filed in boy’s beating death”, Carolina Morning News, Mar. 26; “Editorial: Don’t judge Belman family for filing lawsuit”, Carolina Morning News, Mar. 26; “Chronology of a tragic day”, Carolina Morning News, Mar. 26; Noah Haglund, “Trial to begin in McCracken student’s death”, Hilton Head Island Packet, Mar. 14).
Comments are closed.