Defeat the Federal Marriage Amendment

George Will, Lynne Cheney, Arnold Schwarzenegger, Rudolph Giuliani, and Bob Barr are all on record opposing this wretched would-be Constitutional amendment, and they’re right. See Faith Bremner, “Conservatives opposing marriage amendment”, Gannett News Service/The Coloradoan, Dec. 11, 2003. For our earlier posts on the subject, see Feb. 20 and Feb. 25. For a comeback to the ripely absurd “FMA is needed to bolster fertility rates” argument, see Jacob Levy, Volokh Conspiracy, (Jul. 9); for some ribbing of social conservatives who seem determined to borrow the “precautionary principle” from enviro absolutists for this occasion, see Jane Galt’s co-blogger “Mindles H. Dreck” (Jul. 8, Jul. 9). “As for the gay Republicans whose votes Mr. Bush might then lose, Mr. Weyrich [Paul Weyrich, prominent in the Washington religious right] wrote, ‘Good riddance.'” (Carl Hulse and David D. Kirkpatrick, “Senate Braces Itself for Fight on Gay Marriage”, New York Times, Jul. 9). And the same kind sentiments to you, sir!

More: And the Chicago Tribune (Jul. 13), and the Wall Street Journal, and Richard Epstein…. Update Jul. 14: defeated 48-50 on procedural vote. Yet more: Dale Carpenter (U. of Minn. Law School), “The Federal Marriage Amendment: Unnecessary, Anti-federalist, and Anti-democratic”, Cato Institute White Papers, Sept. 23; Rep. Christopher Cox (R-Calif.), “The Marriage Amendment Is a Terrible Idea”, Wall Street Journal, Sept. 28 ($).

5 Comments

  • Two FMA Thoughts

    Much is being blogged about the decline and fall of the Federal Marriage Amendment (best overview I’ve seen is at Overlawyered.com).

    Two quick additional observations…

  • Senate Debating Marriage Amendment

    As you likely know, the US Senate has been debating the Federal Marriage Amendment and is expected to vote in a few days. Overlawyered.com reviews the conservative opposition to the measure and says: “As for the gay Republicans whose votes…

  • More On The Marriage Amendment

    TalkLeft is all too frequently a repository of silly arguments. Consider this reaction to the proposed Federal Marriage Amendment:Hey, Mr….

  • More On The Marriage Amendment

    TalkLeft is all too frequently a repository of silly arguments. Consider this reaction to the proposed Federal Marriage Amendment:Hey, Mr….

  • in re paul m. (marriage, too)

    “dice” from paul m .