A common complaint about abusive class action litigation is that the lawyers rake in the big bucks while the class members walk away with pennies. Still, Overlawyered repeat offender Lakin Law Firm (many entries) may be taking it to a whole new level. The Madison Record reports:
Mark Brown of the Lakin Law Firm bargained a class action lawsuit down to a penny at a hearing before Madison County Circuit Judge Dave Hylla.
The suit alleges that in 1999, Old Kent Mortgage charged three borrowers $100 for a credit report, paid less than that for the report, and improperly retained the difference.
The problem with this theory at the hearing was that apparently Lakin didn’t have any idea how much the bank paid for the reports, couldn’t identify any fraudulent statements made by the bank, and couldn’t produce a contract that was breached. Other than that, the lawsuit seems fine, and I’m sure that each class member will be happy with his penny.
In all seriousness, given that just to bring the suit Lakin had to dig up as its client — the Stevens family — someone who had taken out a mortgage four years earlier (the mortgage was taken out in 1999, and Lakin did not bring the suit until 2003), I suspect that there won’t be a whole lot of other class members making claims anyway. What’s a little odd is that this suit was reportedly filed four years ago and apparently nothing has happened on the case yet.
Incidentally, the Stevens family seems to have very bad luck with banks and mortgages; they and the Lakin Law Firm filed another class action lawsuit against the bank over mortgage closing costs in 2004.
Comments are closed.