Agreeing with EEOC, jury awards demoted boozing truck driver $119,000

In 2009, a driver with Old Dominion Freight Line, Inc., admitted to the company that he had an alcohol problem. The company told him that it would no longer allow him to drive heavy trucks for the firm. (It said it offered him a less safety-sensitive, but also significantly lower-paying, dock job.) The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) stepped in and sued on his behalf under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). It conceded that Old Dominion could (and indeed had to) take the keys away from a heavy truck driver it found to be currently drinking on the job, but contended it had failed in its obligation to “make an individualized determination as to whether the driver could return to driving and provide a reasonable accommodation of leave to its drivers for them to obtain treatment.” Of course backsliding and remission are common following rehab treatment, which means as a group drivers with known past alcohol problems will have a higher risk profile than drivers without. That is why at an earlier stage of the case I asked, “Are we really required to take chances with 18-wheelers on the highway?”

Now we know the answer: Yes. A jury agreed with the EEOC and awarded the driver $119,000 in back pay.

P.S. On the other hand, upholding the decision of a federal district court in Georgia, the Eleventh Circuit has ruled that Crete Carrier Corp. did not violate the ADA when it declined to employ a truck driver with a “current clinical diagnosis of alcoholism,” a bar to driving under DOT regulations.


  • […] Further, I’m amazed that people are praising the fact that a Justice came to the State of the Union so intoxicated that she fell asleep. So much for sober as a judge. The district judge for whom I clerked was so serious about this image, that he wouldn’t even drink a beer in public, lest someone accuse him of judging under the influence. Also, she has fallen asleep in years past, so either she has been drunk before, or she just doesn’t bother staying awake. I’m not sure which is worse. If most people feel asleep at work, due to intoxication, they would be fired. (Although I’m sure EEOC would sue for a violation of the ADA). […]

  • Brilliant! How do you find these things? Would be funny if it weren’t so scary.