When highly-paid sports figures are hurt in car crashes or other accidents, the potential damages are of course enormous, and the incentives to pursue creative litigation options seem to be accordingly sharp. On Oct. 4 we reported on the legal aftermath of a 1997 rented-limo crash that ended the careers of Detroit Red Wings hockey star Vladimir Konstantinov and team masseur Sergei Mnatsakanov and also injured star player Viacheslav Fetisov, who later returned to the ice. We noted then that lawyers for two of the injured team members were suing a car dealer that sold the vehicle involved, on the perhaps creative theory that by making the seat belts too hard to reach it was legally responsible for the passengers’ non-use of them. Now we learn via the New Jersey Law Journal about a different arena of litigation on the injured players’ behalf. It seems they “sought to cash in on New Jersey’s reputation for pro-policyholder jurisprudence” by filing an action seeking $200 million from the National Hockey League’s providers of auto insurance. However, a “unanimous New Jersey appeals court ruled in 2006 that the carriers were not liable, and affirmed a summary dismissal of the coverage suit. The NHL policy, while it covered team vehicles, did not cover drivers who worked for outside limousine companies, even if the limo companies were hired by teams,” according to the panel’s ruling. Now the New Jersey Supreme Court has declined to review that ruling. (Henry Gottlieb, “NHL’s Insurers Score Hat Trick in N.J. Supreme Court”, New Jersey Law Journal, Oct. 29).
Posts Tagged ‘sports’
Update: Baseball players can’t sue over fantasy baseball statistics
As a Judge Morris Arnold opinion holds (h/t Slim) baseball players can’t prohibit fantasy baseball players from playing games based on their statistics. Earlier: May 2006; April 2005.
Not only does this post allow me to celebrate one of my favorite judges, but I can also use this platform to note that Kenny Lofton was out: not because he didn’t beat Manny Ramirez’s throw into second base (he did), but because he bounced off the bag afterwards while still being tagged.
Cory Lidle, One Year Later
The AP brings us up to date on the anniversary of Cory Lidle’s death:
By one estimate, more than $63 million worth of lawsuits now trail the estate of Yankees pitcher Cory Lidle, seeking compensation for injuries, damages or insurance payouts that followed his plane’s crash into a New York City apartment building.
A year after the wreck, a federal safety panel has concluded that Lidle and his flight instructor died because they misjudged a turn, but the finding has done little to settle the legal fights that now stretch across the country.
According to the article, Lidle’s estate isn’t nearly large enough to pay all the claims against it… unless, of course, Lidle’s widow wins her $100 million lawsuit against the plane’s manufacturer.
Hockey star: seat belt sank into cushions, car dealer should pay
Have you noticed the annoying tendency of seat belts in certain vehicles, such as airport limos, to sink so deep into the cushions that you can crack your fingernails trying to pull them out? Now a lawsuit against a Ford dealership seeks to blame that phenomenon for the 1997 injuries that ended the career of Detroit Red Wings hockey star Vladimir Konstantinov and team masseur Sergei Mnatsakanov. The two were seriously injured when their driver, who was driving on a suspended license following a long series of roadway infractions, veered off Woodward Avenue into a tree. Neither of the injured men was wearing a seat belt, which they blame on the “design defect” that prevented the belts from being “easily accessible”. The car dealership, Findlay Ford Lincoln Mercury, “argues it did not manufacture the limo or carry out modifications that were made to it and the dealership had no reason to know about or be liable for any alleged defects.” (Paul Egan, “Court to hear arguments in Konstantinov crash suit”, Detroit News, Aug. 22). Also see Nov. 25 (other litigation arising from crash).
Jackpot justice: Anucha Browne Sanders
Granted: sexual harassment is wrong, and we at Overlawyered do not approve of it. I have no reason to side with one party or the other in the he-said/she-said dispute in the lawsuit against Isiah Thomas, James Dolan, and the owners of the New York Knicks, MSG, though one questions the relevance of Stephon Marbury’s sexual exploits with a third party and whether that salacious testimony perhaps prejudiced the jury. But even if one agrees that everything Anucha Browne Sanders alleged occurred? Well, that $11.6 million award—which does not even include a penny of economic damages—is outrageous. Hey, I’ll let Isiah Thomas call me a bitch for a hundredth that amount. Given the Supreme Court’s command that punitive damages have some reasonable relationship to compensatory damages, it is hard to understand why a jury was allowed to make an eight-digit award when there has yet to be any compensatory damages established.
ADA lawsuit closes kids’ basketball camp
In Rancho Cordova, Calif., a 50,000-square-foot kids’ indoor sports complex has closed operations following a lawsuit over its lack of wheelchair access. A financial angel, however, has offered to donate a $35,000 lift for free, and Basketball Town’s executive director is cautiously optimistic, saying there is a 50/50 hope that it might reopen. “The original lawsuit was filed by a Solano County man who is a quadriplegic. He says he was unable to attend his nephew’s birthday party on the mezzanine floor last year. Since then, the building’s owner and the tenants who run Basketball Town have clashed over who should pay for the retrofitting.” Derrick Ross of Suisun City has “filed similar lawsuits against two Northern California businesses in the last two years over Americans with Disabilities Act compliance issues.” (Stan Oklobdzija, “Sports complex to close”, Sacramento Bee, Sept. 30; Dave Marquis, “Basketball Town’s Future in the Air”, Oct. 1; Chuck Shepherd’s News of the Weird Daily).
Suspended NFL players file disabled-rights claims
Middle linebacker Odell Thurman of the Cincinnati Bengals and Tampa Bay Bucs cornerback Torrie Cox, both suspended for repeat violations of the National Football League’s substance abuse policy, filed complaints with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission alleging discrimination on the basis of being regarded as disabled, with alcoholism being the disability. The Americans with Disabilities Act has been construed to prohibit discrimination against rehabilitated alcoholics, but not to protect current substance abuse. However, the line distinguishing behavior regarded as current from that regarded as past can be hazy. (Len Pasquarelli, “Bengals’ Thurman, Bucs’ Cox file discrimination claims against NFL”, ESPN.com, Aug. 17). Paul Secunda discusses at Workplace Law Prof (Aug. 23).
Fans sue relocating sports teams
“Two Sonics and Storm season-ticket holders plan to file a lawsuit today, accusing the new team owners of defrauding ticket buyers who believed assurances that they intended to keep the teams in Seattle.” The franchises have announced plans to move to Oklahoma City, but some fans say it won’t be as much fun to watch them in the mean time knowing they’re destined to leave. Seattle personal injury lawyer Michael Myers is representing Carolyn Bechtel and Patrick Sheehy in the suit, which was arranged by Save Our Sonics and Storm, a local group trying to block the move. (Jim Brunner, Seattle Times, Oct. 1). Separately, Seattle city officials have sued on different grounds: “The city wants a court order forcing the team to play out its lease at KeyArena through September 2010 instead of paying a cash settlement to leave early.” Owners say the team lost $17 million playing in Seattle last year. (“Blame flies as city sues Sonics”, Sept. 25).
Class-action suit against New England Patriots
By reader acclaim: “A New York Jets season-ticket holder filed a class-action lawsuit Friday against the New England Patriots and coach Bill Belichick for ‘deceiving customers.'” Carl Mayer of Princeton Township, N.J., is suing over revelations that the Patriots unlawfully videotaped signals from Jets coaches in a Sept. 9 game. Mayer and his attorney, Bruce Afran,
calculated that because customers paid $61.6 million to watch eight “fraudulent” games, they’re entitled to triple that amount — or $184.8 million — in compensation under the federal Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organization Act and the New Jersey Consumer Fraud Act.
Mayer and Afran, who consider themselves public interest lawyers, have been thorns in the side of New Jersey politicians for years, filing lawsuits and demanding investigations to advance their grievances. They are well known in the state but generally have had little success in their causes.
Both have lost bids for elected offices, and Mayer once served as a presidential campaign adviser to Ralph Nader.
(Dennis Waszak Jr., “Jets fan sues Pats, seeks $184 million”, AP/Boston Globe, Sept. 28; ProFootballTalk “Rumor Mill”, Sept. 28). More: Sadly, No!.
New book on golf law
San Diego lawprof John “Jack” H. Minan’s “The Little Green Book of Golf Law”, published by the ABA and hitting bookstores about now, treats of errant balls and many other legal issues that arise in the Wodehouse-beloved outdoor game. I would note that “Iowa golfer Walter Olson”, portrayed unflatteringly in one of the stories, is guaranteed a different person from and unrelated to me. (Tod Leonard, “Law doesn’t control way ball bounces”, San Diego Union-Tribune, Sept. 11).